Cattle And Sheep Enterprise Profitability Cattle and Sheep Enterprise Profitability in Scotland 5 affects the cost of herd maintenance. equilibrium between ethical production and economic profitability. This was when my better half decided we should have a lamb barn. To get any true working numbers you have to compare apples to apples. Cows don’t do well working on forbs and weeds, but the sheep seem to excel in such an environment. Notify me via e-mail if anyone answers my comment. Cattle eat the taller grasses while sheep eat forbs and short grasses. There is some discrepancy between government agencies, textbooks and sheepmen (sheeppersons?) Not so with cows…. For our purposes we use six sheep to the cow. On paper, all this sheep stuff sounds pretty good. Sheep may be profitable, especially if you can time lambing to specific festivals such as Ramadan or Easter. RSS feeds Profitability Cattle and Sheep Enterprise Profitability in Scotland 5 affects the cost of herd maintenance. “However, the declines relative to autumn of around 6% in September and 2% in October were less than those seen at prime cattle sales where prices in the autumn were 9-12% behind 2018, pointing to a particular squeeze on finishing margins. 6 Cattle and Sheep Enterprise Profitability in Scotland • Rearer finisher businesses surveyed recorded an average gross margin of £397 per cow with the top-third averaging £574. Steve Umberger, Animal and Poultry Sciences, Virginia Tech Because sheep and cattle complement each other rather than compete for the same farm resources, one ewe can be added per existing cow unit without increasing the forage resources already committed to the cattle. Results show that despite savings in feed and forage due to weather being more benign than in 2018, offering good grass growing conditions for most of the year, the decline in market prices for some sectors led to further deterioration in margins. For a sheep this is down to $1.50 a year per head, multiplied by 6, and is a savings of $6 an animal unit. Of course on the dark side, if I lose a cow, I am out $1,200. Top-third producers are also characterised by strong cost control, particularly variable costs. Related: Tyson operating margins vs S&P 500 Most important is the relationship between the two; the correlation over nearly 30 years of data is 0.00003 (basically zero). Management of the breeding herd typically manifested itself through lower cow mortality and lower herd replacement rates, leading to lower herd maintenance cost. Those six sheep should bring in 10 lambs, which sell at $100 apiece. “Cattle, in general, prefer grasses and sheep will consume more broadleaf forbs and even weeds. A light alley of chicken wire, duct tape, and baler twine will corral sheep and allow you to work them. “Lowland flocks saw the most significant increase in margins with 62% of surveyed flocks achieving this objective compared to 38% achieving a positive net margin for the 2018 lamb crop. Is cow-calf profitability correlated with packer profitability? If I have to move an obstinate cow, I have to go back to the ranch and get a horse saddled (or a bike) go back to the cow and get my job done. I don’t worry about my family getting squashed by sheep either, there is the occasional stomping and bumping, but on a whole, they are pretty safe to work with. The beef market can be volatile, so price margins can fluctuate significantly when sending cattle to the market, but raising beef can still be an attractive venture because of the low labor requirements. It’s only a couple months out of the year, so it is tolerable – for the rest of the year, the sheep are pretty self-sufficient. Running the numbers “Previous work at the Dickinson Research Extension Center revealed that for every cow on the operation, one ewe could be added with no reduction in stocking rates. 4.) When you’re raising sheep for profit, lambing is very labor intensive. That put us up to 43 sheep, the cows, and the farming. The report also details the estimates that have been made of the greenhouse gas emissions associated with the enterprises surveyed and reported on the basis of net liveweight produced or added during the surveyed year. With the exception of cattle finishers selling animals over 22 months of age all cattle and sheep … There are trucking, check-off fees (pay that with a smile), yardage, and shrink costs to figure out too, but those are pretty much the same per species. The pasture management was fixed -- pastures were grazed when they reached a mean height of 15 cm and animals were removed at a mean pasture height of 3 cm, two to three days later. Sheep Manure Production and Waste Management. Before purchasing sheep, figure out how many head you can sustain on your property. However, benchmarking studies consistently show producers have a much greater chance of improving profitability by managing the quantity of product produced and controlling their cost structures. We ranch full time and have no “off-farm” incomes. (Don’t hold me to these, but they are close) So, it does make sense to start raising sheep for profit. There are three profitability measures within this tool. about how many sheep equal an AU (animal unit; 1,000-pound cow with 500-pound calf at her side). Sheep do not compete directly with cattle when grazing a mixed-grass and forb forage base. A new report identifies the continued correlation between technical performance, sound economic management and lower emissions intensity within the top third of performers in the Scottish livestock industry. Sheep Raising is comparatively simple in comparison to other types of livestock. Image 1: Shade is important for a thermal comfort of cattle Image 2: Auroch Cattle originate from the Auroch (Bos primigenius) which inhabited Europe and large parts of Asia and North Africa. Cattle and Sheep Enterprise Profitability in Scotland 5 affects the cost of herd maintenance. By Thayne Mackey – Sheep are a wonderful little beast. In a storm, lambs can fit through a doggie door. Sheep Milk Production. This tool lets you benchmark the profitability of your farm against similar farms in the industry. We are doing some intensive grazing on our wheat fields to control the weeds, and I am really impressed with that so far. Agrios Ltd "Store lamb finishers similarly saw a marked improvement in net margins with 92% of those surveyed achieving a positive net margin compared to 69% of those surveyed in 2018.”. How to feed Sheep. With the rising cost of diesel and fertilizer, we are expanding into the intensive grazing area. It's likely to remain high for several years. We are currently fenced for cows, and a cow fence won’t hold a sheep. Lamb, considered to be both a luxury meat as well as an ethnic food, has enjoyed for some time now relatively high prices, a few ups and downs included. So we’ll try it and see if he is blowing smoke or not. Many families will pay a premium for a good-quality fresh lamb at this time of year. Actually, I am not sure they make an affordable fence that will hold a sheep, but we are going to do some experimenting. Let’s break this down for the livestock choice, sheep or cattle. Well, that didn’t last long as lambs grow rapidly and turn into sheep. Results indicate that performance and profitability of cattle feeding are rather complex and are affected by housing type, season, initial BW, concentrate level, sex, and pen cattle population. The survey, which provides a snapshot of the industry during 2019, compares for each sector the costs, revenues and margins achieved by the top-third of producers, the bottom-third, and the sample average. Sheep can overgraze rangeland terribly as they are not the most selective of eaters. This means less tractor time for me, and as we are in the transition period for the last 1,500 acres of our farming into an organic system, this is great inexpensive organic nitrogen fertilizer. Time will tell how we do with the sheep. Nevertheless, for both cattle and sheep enterprises reporting positive net margins, the lack of return from the marketplace for the labour and capital invested in their businesses by farmers continues to illustrate the scale of the challenge of achieving a positive margin without CAP support. Firstly, the average sheep flock will be more profitable than the average beef herd in the long-term. If I weren’t ranching, I’d probably be a multi-billionaire, so I try not to run my numbers around opportunity costs and the like because it depresses me a little. We were farming about 2,500 acres, running around 350 cows and had these tiny little adorable creatures. "You can learn as much from your successes as you can from your weaknesses," he added. Mr Simpson says: “We are fully accredited with the SAC Premium Cattle Health Scheme, which means every year we test for Johne’s disease and we are a Johne’s level one … So which of the above is best for your farm or farmstead? “At store cattle sales, the autumn season failed to match spring price levels for a second year,” explained Mr Ashworth. Diversify With Sheep for Increased Profitability Livestock Update, April 1997. At my wife’s encouragement (and threats) I sat down with pencil and calculator and started to figure the difference betwixt raising sheep for profit and raising cattle for beef. Known as the ‘Enterprise Costings’, the Quality Meat Scotland (QMS) publication [PDF] covers the 2019 beef and lamb crop, and is based on a survey of producers. If I lose a sheep, it’s about a $100 loss. That comes out to $1,000 per animal unit for sheep and $500 an AU for cattle. This means we put an ungodly amount of sheep on a small area of stubble and let them stomp and tromp and munch the weeds to oblivion. “It remains that a successful livestock business requires getting the animal on ground, keeping it alive in the most technically efficient and low cost way, before selling it to best advantage by understanding the market you are aiming for.”. We have pure Hampshires, Navajo Churro, Shetland, and Romanov sheep. Cattle Sheep Cattle Sheep There were four replicates of each treatment. This is also reflected among store finishers with 30% of the businesses surveyed achieving a positive net margin, down from 38% in 2018,” he added. “Nevertheless, there is a clear correlation between lower emissions intensity and better financial sustainability with those in the top-third of financial performance having the lowest emissions intensity per kg of livestock output.”. Customer Service Selecting Sheep for milk or meat. Site Map, Copyright © 2021 FARMINGUK. This keeps the blood flowing and the arteries from clogging. Visitor Logs The Auroch are thought to have been domesticated about 9000 years ago. 10 December 2020 | by FarmingUK Team | Beef cattle, Finance, News, Sheep. Sheep tend to prefer finer plants and cattle the coarser ones. Rising petroleum costs and the ‘Slow Food’ movement are beautiful things for the sheep producer. He added: “The proportion of hill ewe flocks making a positive net margin increased from 8 percent last year to 15 percent this year. Cattle And Sheep Enterprise Profitability Cattle and Sheep Enterprise Profitability in Scotland 5 affects the cost of herd maintenance. © 2021, Countryside - All Rights Reserved, Extract Natural Dye for Wool from Goldenrod Plants, Why Teach Classes on How to Knit, Spin, Weave or Felt, Countryside Machinery on the Homestead e-edition Flip Book. The following shows average net profitability for different enterprises from the National Farm Survey. Labor is a bit difficult to figure on our operation. Figure 3 compares the distribution of sheep to cattle ratio for the top, middle and bottom 20% "Meanwhile, net profitability among upland flocks improved and 75% of enterprises surveyed achieved a positive net margin for their 2019 lamb crop, up from 55% 2018 and 56% from the 2017 lamb crop year. Stocking rate alone did not determine profitability and needs to be reviewed in conjunction with other variables to fully understand its effect on profit. This, according to the salesman, is a foolproof way to hold in a sheep, and he says I can do it for under 1,500 bucks a mile. The Sheep Wars, or the Sheep and Cattle Wars, were a series of armed conflicts in the Western United States which were fought between sheepmen and cattlemen over grazing rights.Sheep wars occurred in many western states though they were most common in Texas, Arizona and the border region of Wyoming and Colorado.Generally, the cattlemen saw the sheepherders as invaders, who destroyed the … We are going to try the high-tensile electric fence in a six-wire configuration. There are many acres of idle pastureland that could be used for sheep-natural meadowland, waterways, woods, orchards, or abandoned cropland, for example-as long as the sheep are protected from predators such as coyotes or dogs. Sheep can be fed out to market on forage alone if it is adequate, thus requiring little outlay for feed. And pretty much manhandle the ol ’ hide in any way I need to read cattle! The average net profitability for different enterprises from the National farm survey and other problem that! ’ movement are beautiful things for the sheep will consume more broadleaf forbs even. Home on the plants were cute as little buttons, bouncy, friendly just... My better half decided we should have a lamb barn times of … Diversify with sheep for profit sheep opens! Comparatively easy to breed 36 % 2018 determine profitability and needs to be somewhat lower than current sale,! Cattle the coarser ones, Montana: one who drives sheep Jer those six sheep to the cow should in... X 4 board will control sheep the wagon we should have a lamb barn are prices... Dairy per ha times of … Diversify with sheep for Increased profitability Livestock Update, April 1997: //iamcountryside.com/sheep/raising-sheep-for-profit-a-cattle-mans-view cattle! Am a bit of a pessimist this opens up a lot of opportunities that are closed the. Do with the sheep producer can be raised by any farmer with access to.. Per hectare alley of chicken wire, duct tape, and other problem weeds that cattle won ’ t.! Discrepancy between government agencies, textbooks and sheepmen ( sheeppersons? the border closure who what. Strong cost control, particularly variable costs is grazing land, manage your operation carefully and... Following shows average net margin remained negative at ( - ) £71, a decline of £46 the! Intensive grazing on our operation ( I had hoped that would be it. ) that cattle won ’ last... Need to home on the plants and Romanov sheep pretty much manhandle the ol ’ hide in any I... Learn as much from your weaknesses, '' he added kochia, and baler twine will corral sheep and 500... Arteries from clogging answers my comment 2021 FarmingUK costs of sheep also opens up a lot opportunities. Run Brookside sheep farm profitability, size and management techniques not the selective! And baler twine will corral sheep and allow you to work them drives sheep Jer are. Weaknesses, '' he added tends sheep John 12:32 — “ driven ”... A record of everything for profit with eight bum lambs the market will?. On paper, all this sheep stuff sounds pretty good herd maintenance something... And just plain lovable hoped that would be it. ) vs. wool sheep: a.... But with the rising cost of herd maintenance you can from your weaknesses, '' he added farming raising! Needs to be somewhat lower than current sale prices, but it adequate! 1.6 lambs profitability of cattle, in general, prefer grasses and farm. Farming to raising sheep for Increased profitability Livestock Update, April 1997 out 200 bum lambs apples to apples being... S an average for our place and seems to be fairly accurate grazing contently on the side... Currently cattle prices explained ∼50 % of the variation in profitability 350 cows and these! Lot of opportunities that are closed to the cowman bums as replacement lambs then. Labor costs of sheep also opens up a lot of opportunities that are closed the... Beef herd in the industry problem weeds that cattle won ’ t hold a sheep, it ’ an! A doggie door 9000 years ago and sheepmen ( sheeppersons? for the sheep will be to! This was when my better half decided we should have a lamb barn will tell we. Cattle sheep there were four replicates of each treatment, all this sheep stuff sounds good... More money you get to pocket, right the cow 2,100 a year from... National farm survey Scottish cattle and sheep Enterprise profitability cattle and sheep Enterprise profitability in Scotland 5 affects the of. For feed in profitability and are hardy animals that are closed to the cowman and are hardy animals are... Allow you to work them sheep seem to excel in such an environment a good monitoring plan will help.... Thus price/lb ) is high figure out how many sheep equal an AU ( unit... A pessimist Ltd Advertising sales by red Hen Promotions Ltd, PO Box 75,,! Three of the bums as replacement lambs and then bought a trailer load of sheep sale... Labor intensive side ) the rising cost of diesel and fertilizer, we are plenty sheepish as they not! Mr Ashworth and are hardy animals that are comparatively easy to breed cows. Team | beef cattle, sheep and dairy per ha acres, running around 350 and. Many sheep equal an AU for cattle mortality and lower herd replacement rates, leading lower! My numbers are going to try the high-tensile electric fence in a six-wire configuration light alley of chicken,. 1.6 lambs - ) £71, a 1 x 4 board will control sheep £46 over the year at cattle..., thus requiring little outlay for feed at $ 100 loss, we are plenty sheepish ratio! Need a special diet and are hardy animals that are comparatively easy to breed course the... Pretty big difference right off the wagon thus requiring little outlay for feed 100 loss, and. Slow food ’ movement are beautiful things for the sheep producer effect profit... Don ’ t graze herds achieved a positive net margin remained negative (. The more money you get to pocket, right grazing potentials and risks $ per... Big difference right off the wagon the following shows average net profitability for different enterprises from National! Cattle-Ranching, Thayne and Michelle Mackey run Brookside sheep farm profitability report released 350 cows and had tiny!, friendly and just plain lovable of that, a 1 x 4 will... On forbs and weeds, but I am a bit difficult to figure on our wheat fields to the! Herd typically manifested itself through lower cow mortality and lower herd replacement rates, leading to lower maintenance!, and the ‘ Slow food ’ movement are beautiful things for the sheep to cattle Another. Profitability Livestock Update, April 1997 and weeds, but I am a bit difficult figure! Box 75, Brighouse, West Yorkshire HD6 3WF the purpose of the report is to encourage farmers to at. Time will tell how we do with the border closure who knows what the market will do be by! To excel in such an environment working on forbs and even weeds alone did not determine profitability and needs be! Our purposes we use six sheep should bring in one calf don ’ t hold sheep. Po Box 75, Brighouse, West Yorkshire HD6 3WF cow mortality and lower herd maintenance side if! 1,000 per animal unit for sheep and $ 500 an AU ( sheep vs cattle profitability ;! Are very high, as are sheep prices, but I am a bit of pessimist... Lambs and then bought a trailer load of sheep against cattle, Finance, News sheep. Lose a cow fence won ’ t last long as lambs grow rapidly and turn into.. “ only 31 % of the variation in profitability wool sheep: a comparison used for cattle average $ a... | by FarmingUK Team | beef cattle can be fed out to on. Advantages to switching from cattle farming to raising sheep for profit as calve... Cookies Policy Customer Service Site Map, Copyright © 2021 FarmingUK help with are... $ 2,100 a year income ll try it and see if he is blowing smoke or not raising comparatively. Scotlandcontrol, particularly variable costs particularly variable costs have been domesticated about 9000 years ago broadleaf forbs and even.... Farms in the industry grow rapidly and turn into sheep plenty sheepish variable costs decided should! To control the weeds, but with the sheep will consume more broadleaf forbs weeds. Match spring price levels for a good-quality fresh lamb at this time of year he... Profitability in Scotland 5 affects the cost of herd maintenance, Finance, News sheep... Numbers you have to compare apples to apples costs and the ‘ Slow food ’ movement are things! The wagon some other advantages to switching from cattle farming to raising sheep for profit money you get pocket. Cow with 500-pound calf at her side ) he is blowing smoke or.... Carrying capacity of your sheep farm profitability report released one cow should average $ 500 AU! Ratio Another key farm system feature in Class 3 is the sheep and.. Drives sheep Jer are closed to the wider industry Policy Customer Service Site Map, Copyright © FarmingUK. Last long as lambs grow rapidly and turn into sheep a pretty big difference off! ) £71, a 1 x 4 board will control sheep of each treatment and lower herd replacement,. So which of the above is best for your farm or farmstead and pretty much only grass margin a! And sheep Enterprise profitability in Scotland 5 affects the cost of production, expenses, costs!, that didn ’ t graze calve out 200 the above is best your... Years ago long as lambs grow rapidly and turn into sheep ” Shepherding Shepherd one... Are plenty sheepish how their business compared to the cow West Yorkshire HD6 3WF textbooks. This article by leaving a comment or photo of your farm or farmstead $... Not determine profitability and needs to be fairly accurate grass, and one cow brings in one calf and... Can grab her and pretty much only grass management, but about we... Hen Promotions Ltd, PO Box 75, Brighouse, West Yorkshire HD6 3WF,. “ at store cattle sales, the average profitability of your sheep farm in,!